Everybody loves a winner! We’re tickled pink by the tremendous response we’ve had to the recent Wall Street Journal roundup of American Cheese Society award-winning cheeses. Check out the full Saxelby selection of ACS award-winners and assemble a blue ribbon-worthy cheese plate of your own!
SOFT & CREAMY
Decadent gooey cheeses are a must-have for any cheese plate! Serve with a spoonful of honey or your favorite preserves. Soft cheeses should ideally be eaten within 2 weeks of purchase, so we recommend buying only as much as you need for your next few dinners.
Harbison: Gooey, bark-wrapped cheese. Cultured cream, mustard, and raspberry flavor notes
Noble Road: Mild, mushroomy Brie-style cheese
Moses Sleeper: Funky soft-ripened cow’s milk cheese. Broccoli, truffle, and creamy flavor notes
For those who love the funk, a pungent washed-rind cheese is a must have in any cheese lineup! These savory and potent cheeses are a perfect foil for wine and beer pairings – try an off-dry riesling or a creamy brown ale.
Grayson: Beefy, custardy washed-rind cow’s milk cheese
Slyboro: Pungent vegetal washed-rind goat’s milk cheese
AGED & STRONG
These mature cheeses pack a punch! Sturdy and robust, these cheeses provide richness, depth and heft to a cheese plate, and will hold up practically forever in your fridge! Don’t be afraid to stock up and savor these over the course of many weeks.
Marieke Premium Gouda: Butterscotchy, crystalline, and carmelized aged gouda
Cabot Clothbound Cheddar: Nutty, brothy, grassy, and sweet clothbound cheddar
In the world of cheese, it’s not a bad thing to have the blues! Blue cheeses can range from mild-mannered to kick-you-in the-pants in terms of their flavor intensity, but we always like to end a cheese course with a little blue. Pair with bold red wines, fortified dessert wines like port, sherry, and madiera, or even with spirits like bourbon and whiskey.
Cayuga Blue: Goat’s milk blue with mushroom, vanilla, and black pepper notes
Bayley Hazen Blue: Rich, fudgy cow’s milk blue with chocolate and anise flavor notes
Ewe’s Blue: Bright, buttermilk-y, and fruity sheep’s milk blue
Dunbarton Blue: A cheddar/blue hybrid with sweet, toasted nut and burnt sugar flavor notes